I just found this fantastic list of so many handmade selling sites and their traffic rankings. I had to share. http://shinyadornments.com/wordpress Thank you Kristy! All this work you've done and the information you've shared is fantastic.
Check out http://artfire.com which hasn't even officially opened yet! They have extensive marketing plans and plan on featuring artists, unlike other handmade sites who focus on gathering more and more shops exclusively, which drowns out loyal shops